I still say Regions are not useful…but…

June 2, 2008

There was quite a bit of uproar regarding my rant about C# regions. At the time, I was looking through a lot of really bad code, and I was pretty peeved at how all the pieces of complex code were hidden away by Visual Studio.  However, some of the comments seemed to imply that there is no such thing as “perfect” or “good” code when you refer to code written by someone other than yourself. And, to be honest, that is true: I like to think the code I write is better than most other developers. However, I want to qualify what better is:

Better code is:

  • Code that is tested
  • Code that is maintainable
  • Code that is understandable by someone other than me
  • Code that is changeable by someone other than me

Even with those guidelines, there is still some room to define more terms, but we have to stop at some point. Notice how none of these points really points to Lines of Code, the degree of algorithm obfuscation or how low the average cyclomatic complexity is for your codebase. These bullet points take a professional approach to the software development profession. That is, I and many others are professionals, and we should write our code as professionals. I hold myself to the same high standards as I hold others. Granted, I don’t meet those standards all the time either. I try not to beat myself up about it, because I would never win.

However, I wanted to be less emotional about why regions are really not that great. Just flat out, the main reason I see is that when you encapsulate code in region blocks, you miss an opportunity for one of many refactorings. In other words, you are knowingly violating principles of good software development by hiding the “bad” code under the rug.

Regions are simply comments preprocessor-style comments. As with normal comments, they are removed before the code is compiled, and are only there to help our non-digital brains cope with the mess we created in the first place.

I try my best to follow the TDD (and by extension, BDD) methodology, and so far, I have found no need for regions. Ever. I find that they clutter the code. I also find that TDD manages the mess I create much better than regions because they are like little pieces of thoughts that stick around to keep verifying my intentions several features back. TDD is by no means a do all methodology, but it has saved my butt several times, and does tend to make you write code that is neat, well tested, well organized and region free.


4 Responses to “I still say Regions are not useful…but…”

  1. […] I still say Regions are not useful…but… […]

  2. […] say No! to C# Regions and I still say Regions are not useful… but… (Saul […]

  3. […] ExtractMethod, I still say Regions are not useful… but… […]

  4. […] ExtractMethod, I still say Regions are not useful… but… […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: